Buried By Critics: Minecraft Rotten Tomatoes Score Is In

Warner Bros. has another big dud on its hands – at least according to critics – as the first batch of reviews has hit Rotten Tomatoes for A Minecraft Movie, and they’re “rotten.”

Update: Box office numbers are out of this world.

The film adapts the popular video game and stars Jack Black as Steve, who teams up with four misfits who are pulled into the world of Minecraft, played by Jason Momoa as “The Garbage Man,” Emma Myers as Natalie, Danielle Brooks as Dawn, and Sebastian Hansen as Henry. Jennifer Coolidge also stars as Vice Principal Marlene.

This blocky world runs on imagination, and to get home, they must learn to survive and defend it from Piglins, Zombies, and other dangers. They team up with Steve (Black), an expert crafter, to complete their quest. Along the way, they’ll rediscover their creativity—the key to thriving both in Minecraft and the real world.

It has also been announced an extended preview of James Gunn’s Superman will be playing in front of the film.

What is the Minecraft movie Rotten Tomatoes score?

With the first 45 reviews, the Minecraft Rotten Tomatoes Score is currently at 53%. The fan score will be available once the film is released, starting with Thursday previews and officially on Friday.

What do the reviews say?

The good:

Jack Black & Jason Momoa’s Chemistry

Many critics agree: the chaotic duo of Jack Black and Jason Momoa is a highlight. They bring energy, silliness, and fun that give the movie its goofy, off-the-wall charm.

“The comedic duo we didn’t know we needed.” – Peter Gray, The AU Review
“Surprisingly fun and positive… also accessible for non-fans.” – Grace Randolph

Faithful to Minecraft’s Spirit

Some found that it captured the game’s “sandbox” vibe and limitless creativity.

“Captures the ‘anything can happen’ spirit.” – Travis Hopson, Punch Drunk Critics
“A breath of fresh air after so many family films that seem preordained by lore.” – Jordan Hoffman, Entertainment Weekly

Fun for Kids and Families

It lands well with younger audiences and is described as “uproariously good fun” by FILMINK.

“Kids, whether they’re fans of the game or not, will likely enjoy it.” – Meredith G. White, Arizona Republic

Director Jared Hess’ Style

Some critics appreciated Hess’ absurdist, playful direction, likening it to Napoleon Dynamite.

“Fully and hilariously a Jared Hess movie.” – Sean P. Means, The Movie Cricket
“More identity here than most factory-line adaptations.” – Brandon Yu, NYT

The bad:

Lack of Depth or Coherence

Many say the movie is a surface-level, chaotic mess, relying on IP recognition without any real storytelling.

“Pointless… dearth of consequence.” – Trace Sauveur, AwardsWatch
“Clunky mess lacking in genuine imagination.” – Soren Andersen, Seattle Times

Unfunny & Poor CGI

A few call it one of the worst video game adaptations yet, citing painful humor and “uncanny CGI.”

“Painfully unfunny… ugly to look at.” – Ryan Guar, Discussing Film

Corporate, Soulless Feel

Common complaint: it feels like a brand-driven cash-in with little love for the source material.

“Cinema in service of nothing more than IP exploitation.” – Nick Schager, Daily Beast
“Saw infinite possibilities… and chose the one made a thousand times before.” – Jacob Oller, AV Club

Missed Opportunity for Older Fans

It may entertain kids, but adults looking for more nostalgia or deeper storytelling will likely be disappointed.

“Not enough storytelling or humor to get us invested.” – Meredith G. White, Arizona Republic
“Digging straight down: a terrible idea.” – Jonathan Sim, ComingSoon