Did Doctor Who Just Fake a Regeneration to Trick Disney?

Did Doctor Who Just Fake a Regeneration to Trick Disney?

In one of the strangest twists the series has ever pulled, the Doctor Who Season 2 finale ends with Ncuti Gatwa regenerating into Billie Piper’s Rose Tyler.

Fans were left stunned, confused, and scrambling for answers, but at least it created hype, which the series hasn’t had in years.

ncuti gatwa doctor who regeneration

Rumors Point to Desperation Behind the Scene

However, behind the scenes, it might be a different story, as rumors suggest the move wasn’t about storytelling at all (big surprise).

Word is, showrunner Russell T Davies pulled the stunt in a last-ditch effort to get Disney to greenlight a third season on Disney+, and that Billie Piper only agreed as a favor.

billie piper doctor who

Is Billie Piper Really the Next Doctor?

If that is indeed the case, that could mean Billie Piper won’t be sticking around as the 16th Doctor.

Actually, the season finale credits didn’t even state she is the Doctor, as past regeneration scenes have introduced the various actors as the new Timelord.

It’s further claimed that Piper filmed the scene a few weeks ago or so, with only a few members of the crew present.

doctor who david tennant ncuti gatwa

The Regeneration That Makes No Sense

If you are a Doctor Who fan, the Doctor regenerating into Rose makes absolutely no sense.

Also, the Doctor regenerating into the likeness of Rose makes no sense, as following a regeneration, the Doctor wouldn’t know what his new face looks like. It seemed pretty clear he/she knew he/she was Rose Tyler.

Doctor Who: Ncuti Gatwa Fired Claim Latest Rumors

A Gimmick to Save the Show—or the Budget?

So was this a real regeneration or just a flashy gimmick to stir up fake hype and keep the Disney money flowing?

Did Russell T Davies call in a favor from the friend who helped launch her career, hoping a one-off cameo would stir up buzz and push Disney to renew Doctor Who for a third season?

Doctor Who Ncuti Gatwa Christmas Special Said To Be Canceled

Disney+ Reportedly Out After Ratings Flop

Reports have offered that due to such poor viewership – known to be the worst in the show’s 60+ year history – that Disney isn’t going to renew for a Season 3 on Disney+.

It’s known Disney spent a hundred million on Doctor Who that no one watched. Similarly, Disney has even cut back on its own brands that nobody is watching, as both Marvel and Star Wars have seen pullbacks, now Disney is going to drop more money on Doctor Who that has worse viewership than both?

Doctor Who: Disney Demands Removal Of Russell T Davies

Could Russell T Davies Be Replaced?

Rumors also offer Disney is so unhappy with Doctor Who that the condition for a Season 3 renewal is to remove Russell T Davies as the showrunner.

So if Season 3 happens on Disney+, it could be with a new showrunner, but will it be Billie Piper and Rose Tyler as the new Timelord?

Doctor Who David Tennant

What’s Next for Doctor Who?

Separate rumors also offer the BBC is looking for a new backer to continue the series, possibly Sony/Amazon.

If/when Doctor Who does get renewed, it’s looking like new episodes won’t be dropping until at least 2027. Geronimo!

About Matt McGloin

Matt McGloin is the editor-in-chief and publisher of Cosmic Book News, the independent entertainment news site he founded in 2008. He covers movies, comics, TV, video games and pop culture and has reported major industry scoops over the years, including revealing the Avengers: Endgame title ahead of its official announcement. Through Cosmic Book News, he helped Marvel Comics promote Guardians of the Galaxy and Nova through exclusive previews, artwork, and interviews, with the site also quoted in solicitations and on comic covers. He also reported on Marvel’s Daredevil: Born Again retooling before it was later confirmed by the trades.

Recommended

The Mandalorian & Grogu First Reactions Raise Red Flags: ‘Dull,’ ‘Snooze Fest,’ ‘Weakest Star Wars Movies’
The Mandalorian & Grogu First Reactions Raise Red Flags: ‘Dull,’ ‘Snooze Fest,’ ‘Weakest Star Wars Movies’
Daredevil: Born Again Season 2 Loses To Temptation Island On Nielsen
Daredevil: Born Again Season 2 Loses To Temptation Island On Nielsen
Doctor Who Gets New Streaming Home On AMC+ In June
Doctor Who Gets New Streaming Home On AMC+ In June
The Punisher: One Last Kill Review: Jon Bernthal Returns, But Marvel Needed More
The Punisher: One Last Kill Review: Jon Bernthal Returns, But Marvel Needed More
The Punisher: One Last Kill Rotten Tomatoes Score Debuts Strong With Fans And Critics
The Punisher: One Last Kill Rotten Tomatoes Score Debuts Strong With Fans And Critics
Vision Quest First Look Revealed With Robert Downey Jr., Tom Hiddleston, Paul Bettany At Disney Upfronts
Vision Quest First Look Revealed With Robert Downey Jr., Tom Hiddleston, Paul Bettany At Disney Upfronts