The first reactions for James Gunn’s Superman have hit social media, and the verdict is mixed but mostly positive. Critics are calling the movie a colorful, comic book-style adventure packed with heart, humor, and action, though some note that it’s messy and overstuffed.
Critics Praise the Tone and Cast
Many reviewers are highlighting how Superman embraces the optimism of the character, with some calling it the most comic book-accurate live-action Superman movie yet. David Corenswet is getting positive feedback as the new Man of Steel, with Rachel Brosnahan’s Lois Lane also drawing praise. Nicholas Hoult’s Lex Luthor performance seems to be more divisive, with some unsure what to make of it.
Critics say the tone is light, earnest, and occasionally goofy — a clear contrast to the darker, more serious past Superman films from Zack Snyder starring Henry Cavill. Several are comparing it to a live-action Saturday morning cartoon or something straight out of Justice League Unlimited.
Reaction Highlights
- Rachel Leishman calls it a “beacon of hope” and praises its lightness and happiness.
- Scott Menzel says it’s “a mess, narratively and tonally” but finds positives in the performances.
- JoBlo describes it as a “mixed bag”, saying Lois Lane and Clark Kent are short-changed in favor of Superman action.
- Sean O’Connell, Germain Lussier, and Mike Ryan had a blast with the film’s comic book energy and called it a joyful, fun ride.
- Others, like ViewerAnon and GothamGeekGirl, noted problems with the plot structure, exposition, and dialogue.
- Krypto the Superdog is a fan favorite, stealing scenes throughout.
Check out the full reactions below.
The Tone: Love It or Hate It
The overall consensus is that James Gunn delivers a comic-booky, energetic Superman film, but its quirks may not work for everyone. Some praised Gunn’s ability to balance heart and humor, while others thought the movie leaned too heavily into silliness and lacked focus.
There are also mixed opinions on the CGI and pacing, with a few calling out scenes like Superman fighting a Kaiju or escaping an interdimensional prison as feeling episodic rather than part of a cohesive story.
Final Take
Superman looks to be a love letter to the source material, filled with big action, offbeat humor, and an optimistic take on the character. While not perfect, it’s winning over many who have been waiting for a Superman movie with heart and fun.
The full reviews are expected later on Tuesday when the embargo lifts.
Superman officially takes off July 11.
