Photos surfaced Wednesday night from billionaire Michael Rubin’s annual White Party in the Hamptons appearing to show Maguire, 51, kissing rapper Ice Spice, 26, sending social media into a frenzy over the 25-year age gap and the sheer randomness of the pairing.
The images, shot through a balcony railing from outside the party, show the pair standing close together, with one photo appearing to capture a kiss.
Just Jared, which posted the Backgrid photos, described Maguire as “chatting with a woman, who appears to be Ice Spice” — notably stopping short of confirming anything beyond a conversation.
Ice Spice’s Team Responds
A representative for Ice Spice has since shut down the speculation. Per Loren Lorosa of The Breakfast Club, the rapper’s team says the photo angle is deceiving and that the two were simply sharing a vape and talking, with Maguire’s hand on her arm being nothing more than a greeting.
Page Six confirmed both attended the star-studded event — which annually draws everyone from athletes to A-listers — but did not report a kiss or any relationship between the two.
So per the official word: nothing happened. Fans, of course, remain unconvinced, with the photos racking up tens of thousands of likes and Spider-Man jokes flooding the replies — “That’s Peter Parker and Mary Jane, calm down,” reads one comment on the Just Jared post.
The photos also come months after Maguire made headlines for a different rumored romance: back in February, Page Six reported the actor sparked dating rumors with a 20-year-old model following a cozy outing — a 30-year age gap that drew similar reactions online.
Nothing was ever confirmed there either — Maguire’s last confirmed relationship was with model Tatiana Dieteman, which ended in 2021.
Maguire’s Spider-Man In The Spotlight
The timing is something, as Maguire’s Spider-Man is dominating headlines for entirely different reasons: the alleged Avengers: Doomsday plot leak reportedly reveals the movie opens with Maguire’s web-slinger from the Sam Raimi trilogy.
Maguire last played Peter Parker in 2021’s Spider-Man: No Way Home ($1.9 billion worldwide), and Avengers: Doomsday hits theaters December 18, 2026.
