UPDATE 10/29: The fan score isn’t the only number falling: Lanterns is now gone from HBO Max’s top 10 completely, and it dropped off Nielsen’s chart in its finale week.
The Lanterns Rotten Tomatoes fan score is still going down.
A week ago, Lanterns hit 70%, the lowest audience score of any James Gunn DC project.
It has since dropped to 67%.
The critics score hasn’t moved. It still sits at 91%.
Supergirl, the lowest-grossing DC movie ever, holds a 72% fan score. The gap under it keeps getting wider. And Milly Alock just deleted all her Supergirl images from her Instagram.

The Score Fell Through Another Week Of Backlash
The finale aired October 4, and the score has kept falling ever since.
The week in between gave fans plenty to rate.
James Gunn’s 2024 pitch that Lanterns asks what Green Lanterns would be like if they were real went viral on X a week after the finale.
Then the co-host of DC’s official podcast said Lanterns fans “can choke on their own tongues.”
All of it comes on top of the finale backlash that filled Gunn’s own Instagram comments.

The Renewal Call Comes While The Score Drops
This is the backdrop for the Season 2 decision.
DC Studios co-head Peter Safran said this week that fans will hear Season 2’s fate before the end of the year, with a “worthy successor” story out of the writers room the requirement.
Deadline reported a renewal is pending after the finale set a series viewership record.
The viewership and the fan score are telling two different stories. It is the split Cosmic Book News‘ Paramount insider described on September 15.
“Negative engagement might pad the ratings a bit but wrecks ancillary income channels,” the source said.
The ratings keep going up on paper. The people doing the watching keep marking the show down.
Safran says the answer comes by the end of the year. The fans are already giving theirs.
