UPDATE: The Season 2 wait now has an end date, as Peter Safran says the answer comes before the end of the year.
A clip of James Gunn pitching Lanterns as a grounded, terrestrial story is going viral on X.
The clip is from December 2024, when Gunn went on Josh Horowitz’s Happy Sad Confused podcast long before the series premiered.
Fans dug it up Friday night, and it has passed 360,000 views on X.
Note: Spoilers from the Lanterns finale below.

‘They’re On Earth For The Story’
Horowitz asked Gunn what he meant by calling the show grounded, and whether audiences would see superhero costumes.
Gunn opened with, “I don’t think anyone could argue, we’ve never seen a great Green Lantern live action story.”
“Well, I don’t want to give away all that stuff. But I think grounded just like, if Green Lanterns were real, what the f-ck would they be and how would they be?” Gunn said.
“The thing that keeps getting out is it’s a terrestrial story. And I’m like, yeah, because it’s on Earth. The story takes place on Earth,” Gunn laughed. “They’re on Earth for the story, like most Green Lantern stories. It’s terrestrial bound. It’s not in outer space. We don’t have a thousand Green Lanterns, all that stuff.”
“It’s a grounded story that’s being told through another lens,” Gunn added. “It’s an HBO series, and it’s going to be an HBO series. I’m happy with that, and I love the scripts.”

‘Seriously Out Of Touch With The Fandom’
The reposts are not kind.
“James Gunn is coping like somebody who know they dun f-cked up,” posted Verbal Riot in the repost driving most of the views.
“If Green Lanterns were real, they would bang grandmas in parking lots and rob graves?” asked YouTuber Nerdrotic.
That one comes from the show. In Episode 6, John Stewart dug up Hal Jordan’s body to take the ring, and Hal’s relationship with Sheriff Kerry Kane fills in the rest.
“He is seriously out of touch with the fandom. I think deep down he knows Tom King f-cked up but him admitting that would mean he has to admit his DCU is a failure,” posted Nerdygirlcreates.
Tom King co-created the series and spent last week defending the finale letting Hal’s killer walk free, saying “jail isn’t worse than that.”

You Never See Kevin Feige Doing This
No other studio head engages like this.
Kevin Feige has run Marvel Studios for nearly two decades through flops, leaks, and fan revolts. He has never fired back at a fan online. He doesn’t even have a social media account.
Kathleen Kennedy sat through years of Star Wars backlash at Lucasfilm without replying to a single fan.
Gunn does it weekly.
When Lanterns killed off Hal Jordan, Gunn told fans “sorry if you don’t like it.”
When a fan asked who wanted a Clayface movie, Gunn fired back with “Who tf asked for Back to the Future?”
After the Lanterns finale, he spent days in his own Instagram comments answering the backlash.
The viral clip is something different. Gunn isn’t responding to anyone this time. Fans pulled up his own pitch and are grading it against the show he delivered.

No Season 2 Announcement
The clip also lands on a growing pile.
Lanterns ended its season with the lowest Rotten Tomatoes fan score of any James Gunn DC project.
DC Comics legend Grant Morrison called the finale “morally and legally incoherent.”
And the Season 2 order still has not come, with Deadline reporting a renewal is “pending” at HBO after the showrunner confirmed nothing is in development along with the HBO boss.
Back in 2024, Gunn asked the question: if Green Lanterns were real, what would they be?
The fan who posted the clip answered it: “If green lanterns real I guess they would suck.”
