Forbes Blames Zack Snyder Fans For ‘Clayface’ Hate — But There’s A Problem

Forbes Blames Zack Snyder Fans For ‘Clayface’ Hate — But There’s A Problem

Forbes senior contributor Paul Tassi says fake spoilers and misinformation are plaguing the early reactions to Clayface, and he knows who he thinks is behind it.

In an October 12 article, Tassi writes that “anti-fans” have been circulating photos from Clayface screenings with “captions full of hate and alleged spoilers about the film and its plot turns, including its ending.”

Tassi says the fakes are easy to spot because “most of them use the exact same shot someone posted from inside the screening room, suggesting they’re simply faking attendance and their reactions.”

He then points the finger at Zack Snyder fans.

“I would not believe any over-the-top hate you see online, especially since the DCU has a dedicated army of always-online haters in the form of Zack Snyder devotees who miss his DCEU and want him to return and replace James Gunn,” writes Tassi.

Tassi also suggests checking the timelines of accounts posting the leaks to see “just how many tweets are devoted to lambasting James Gunn and the DCU.”

Worth noting: in the same article, Tassi admits he changed his mind on the movie.

“I previously said that I didn’t think the movie would do well, but I have since changed my mind,” he writes.

Tom Rhys Harries in the DCU Clayface movie
Tom Rhys Harries in the DCU Clayface movie

The Presale Numbers Come From Theater Chains

Tassi also pushes back on reports that Clayface presales are running behind Supergirl, writing “if those numbers are even accurate.”

The numbers come from theater chain presale data posted at the Box Office Theory forum, which showed Clayface presales pointing to around a $20 million opening, roughly 80% behind Supergirl at the same point.

That lines up with Boxoffice Pro’s own long-range forecast, which has Clayface opening at $23 million to $33 million, under Supergirl‘s $37.1 million debut.

It also aligns with our ticket sales: we still have the only three tickets for the first premium screening. And it hasn’t changed in a week.

Tassi’s caveats are that Supergirl was a bigger-budget tentpole, that Clayface is a horror movie opening October 23, a week before Halloween, and that it faces little competition that weekend.

However, he forgets that Clayface has zero IMAX screens, which all belong to Street Fighter.

Tom Rhys Harries and Naomi Ackie in Clayface
Tom Rhys Harries and Naomi Ackie in Clayface

The Boycott Calls Are On The Record

The backlash against Clayface did not come out of nowhere.

Fans publicly called for a boycott of the movie after the Lanterns finale killed off Hal Jordan, posting about it under their own names and handles.

James Gunn engaged with the backlash himself, firing back at a “who asked for Clayface” post with “Who tf asked for Back to the Future? Casablanca?”

At the same time, the actual early word on the movie has been good.

The first Clayface review came in at 4 stars following the October 13 LA premiere, with reactions calling it “freakishly awesome” and others giving it a strong recommend.

Superman Henry Cavill and Zack Snyder behind-the-scenes Man of Steel
Superman Henry Cavill and director Zack Snyder behind-the-scenes Man of Steel

Insiders Say The Snyder Return Is In Play

Tassi frames Snyder fans wanting the director to “return and replace James Gunn” as wishful thinking from haters.

Our insiders say otherwise.

As we have been reporting since November 2025, a Zack Snyder return to DC has been in the works, and the plans are still in place at Skydance following the merger.

The project is Frank Miller’s The Dark Knight Returns. Insiders tell us the adaptation is fully storyboarded and being looked at as a two-part event movie, with talk it could grow into a trilogy.

Gal Gadot is already on record: “If Zack comes back to run DC, I’ll come back.” Joe Manganiello just said he would return to play Deathstroke, and that’s after his friend Gunn told him to forget about it.

And the timeline is public. Bloomberg reported that Gunn and Peter Safran’s DC contracts expire in April 2027, six months after the merger closed.

So when fans post about Snyder coming back, they are not inventing it. They are repeating what the reporting says.

So there is real criticism of Clayface, real praise for Clayface, and real reporting on the Snyder return, all of it on the record.

Clayface opens in theaters on October 23. The box office will be the judge.

About Matt McGloin

Matt McGloin is the editor-in-chief and publisher of Cosmic Book News, the independent entertainment news site he founded in 2008. He covers movies, comics, TV, video games and pop culture and has reported major industry scoops over the years, including revealing the Avengers: Endgame title ahead of its official announcement. Through Cosmic Book News, he helped Marvel Comics promote Guardians of the Galaxy and Nova through exclusive previews, artwork, and interviews, with the site also quoted in solicitations and on comic covers. He also reported on Marvel’s Daredevil: Born Again retooling before it was later confirmed by the trades.

Recommended

Ben Affleck Isn’t Done With Superhero Movies
Ben Affleck Isn’t Done With Superhero Movies
First Clayface Review Hits After LA Premiere: 4 Stars, ‘A Little Bit Of Everything’
First Clayface Review Hits After LA Premiere: 4 Stars, ‘A Little Bit Of Everything’
Joe Manganiello Says He Would Return As Deathstroke: ‘You Want A Warrior’
Joe Manganiello Says He Would Return As Deathstroke: ‘You Want A Warrior’
‘Clayface’ Box Office Alarm: Disastrous Presales Put Skydance On Notice
‘Clayface’ Box Office Alarm: Disastrous Presales Put Skydance On Notice
Ben Affleck Calls Batman v Superman ‘A Big Success’ — Now Worth Over $1 Billion
Ben Affleck Calls Batman v Superman ‘A Big Success’ — Now Worth Over $1 Billion
Ben Affleck Rips ‘Justice League’ Studio Interference, Defends Zack Snyder: ‘It Was So Gross’
Ben Affleck Rips ‘Justice League’ Studio Interference, Defends Zack Snyder: ‘It Was So Gross’