‘Clayface’ Exposes James Gunn’s DCU Overseas Problem: Three Movies, Same 43%

Clayface just posted its opening weekend, and the foreign audience did what it has done to every James Gunn DCU movie so far.

It stayed home.

Per Deadline’s Sunday estimates, $24.5 million of Clayface‘s $43 million worldwide start came from North America.

Overseas added $18.5 million.

That puts the split at 57% domestic and 43% international.

Our insiders have argued since last November that the global audience is the difference between Zack Snyder’s DC and Gunn’s. The numbers keep proving them right.

Supergirl Clayface Superman

Three DCU Movies, All Stuck At 43% Overseas

Superman finished with $264.5 million internationally, which was 42.7% of its $618.7 million worldwide total.

Supergirl ended as the lowest-grossing DC movie ever at $126.4 million, with $54.1 million of it coming from overseas. That is a 42.8% share.

Now Clayface sits at 43% international through its opening weekend, after missing France’s daily top 5 and opening below Supergirl in South Korea.

Three movies, three different characters, and the same split.

Gunn blamed the character when Superman stalled overseas, telling Rolling Stone the hero is “not a known commodity in some places” the way Batman is.

Clayface is a Batman spinoff set in Gotham. The foreign audience still is not showing up.

Henry Cavill Zack Snyder

Snyder’s DC Ran 56% To 62% Overseas

Man of Steel earned $379.1 million internationally, 56.6% of its worldwide total.

Batman v Superman pulled $544 million from overseas markets, a 62.2% share.

Those figures do not count inflation. Adjusted, the SnyderVerse passed $3 billion by its third movie, while Gunn’s first two films combined for $745 million. With Clayface, they’re not even at $800M.

In today’s dollars, each of the SnyderVerse’s three movies alone beat all three of Gunn’s flicks together. That shows a lot more tickets were sold for the SnyderVerse.

The gap is the world. Snyder built Superman, Batman, and the Justice League as larger-than-life figures, and overseas markets treated them that way.

The Michael Jackson biopic made the same case last year, finishing past $1 billion with 63.6% of it international.

Clayface bathtub scene

The Insiders Called This In May

When Michael first passed Gunn’s Superman, our insiders compared Superman to Michael Jackson and Elvis: a larger-than-life figure the entire planet already knows.

Puck News backed the point, quoting a banker: “Being global now matters more than ever, and Hollywood fails to see it.”

The same sources say Skydance’s mandate is to “win back the core male audience of DC,” and they describe Snyder as “gung-ho” on a Dark Knight Returns movie and a Justice League finale.

Man of Tomorrow is the test case. It needs the international audience Snyder had to get anywhere near $1 billion.

Clayface just showed the new owners the same numbers the insiders have been pointing at all year.

About Matt McGloin

Matt McGloin is the editor-in-chief and publisher of Cosmic Book News, the independent entertainment news site he founded in 2008. He covers movies, comics, TV, video games and pop culture and has reported major industry scoops over the years, including revealing the Avengers: Endgame title ahead of its official announcement. Through Cosmic Book News, he helped Marvel Comics promote Guardians of the Galaxy and Nova through exclusive previews, artwork, and interviews, with the site also quoted in solicitations and on comic covers. He also reported on Marvel’s Daredevil: Born Again retooling before it was later confirmed by the trades.

Recommended

‘Clayface’ Wins Box Office With $24.5M — But There’s a Problem
‘Clayface’ Wins Box Office With $24.5M — But There’s a Problem
‘Clayface’ Review: DCU’s Gruesome Horror Movie Is a Big Surprise (8/10)
‘Clayface’ Review: DCU’s Gruesome Horror Movie Is a Big Surprise (8/10)
James Gunn Celebrates Clayface’s A- CinemaScore: ‘Really Proud Of This’
James Gunn Celebrates Clayface’s A- CinemaScore: ‘Really Proud Of This’
‘Clayface’ Wins Box Office Battle, Heads For $25 Million Opening
‘Clayface’ Wins Box Office Battle, Heads For $25 Million Opening
Black Adam Would Have Made $500M In Today’s Dollars As Fans Rip Dwayne Johnson On 4-Year Anniversary
Black Adam Would Have Made $500M In Today’s Dollars As Fans Rip Dwayne Johnson On 4-Year Anniversary
Lanterns Misses Nielsen Again, Even With The Finale’s Full Week Counted
Lanterns Misses Nielsen Again, Even With The Finale’s Full Week Counted