Clayface did $2,109,875 on Wednesday. Supergirl did $2,133,462 on its first Wednesday.
Thursday’s estimate for Clayface is $1.9 million. Supergirl‘s first Thursday did $2.3 million.
Deadline now puts Clayface‘s first week at $33.6 million, which backs up that Thursday number.
Clayface has now come in under Supergirl every single day of its release.
And Supergirl finished with $126 million.

A 48% Drop Would Be Generous
The second weekend is underway, and Deadline already expects it to underperform.
Halloween lands on Saturday and pulls audiences out of theaters.
Horror movies usually lead on Halloween. Deadline calls this weekend “an anomaly.”
The outlet has You Can See Everything winning at $10 million-plus. That would put the Elizabeth Holmes documentary at No. 1 one weekend after Clayface beat it for the top spot.
Box Office Theory has Clayface at $12.4 million for the second weekend, which would be a 48% drop.
Supergirl dropped 76.8% in its second weekend and did $8.6 million.
Deadline’s own Friday forecast comes in lower. It has Clayface dropping around 60%, which lands near $9.6 million.
Against the daily numbers, the Box Office Theory call looks generous.
It has Clayface holding up far better than Supergirl did, and Clayface has not beaten Supergirl on a single day yet.

Barely Breaking Even At $115 Million
Some estimators and fans have Clayface finishing between $130 million and $140 million worldwide.
The numbers so far say otherwise.
Through Wednesday, Clayface sits at $52.9 million worldwide.
Break-even is around $110 million on the $44 million budget Variety reported.
Our present guess is a finish of $115 million, barely breaking even.
The international side is not helping.
Clayface has done $21.1 million overseas. Supergirl took in $54.1 million internationally, so Clayface needs another $33 million just to match that.
To beat Supergirl, it has to perform better. It’s not doing that.
This weekend and the next international report will show how close that call is.

Obsession Did Not Drop Like This
Comparisons to Obsession keep coming up, including from James Gunn over the A- CinemaScore.
Obsession did $3.2 million on its first Wednesday and $3.4 million on its first Thursday.
Clayface did not come close to either number.
Obsession also saw a big jump of 39.3% in its second weekend.
And the smaller daily percentage drops for Clayface do not mean much either.
Clayface opened low and is still running low, so the percentages only look good because the dollars are so small.

Even $150 Million Is Not Good For A DC Movie
Clayface carries the DC brand.
Even if it beats every estimate out there and gets to $150 million, that is not a good number for a DC movie.
The budget and the break-even math do not change what the turnout says.
DC fans didn’t ask for it, and the horror fans don’t seem to care.
